ListSource vs. PropStream vs. Goliath Data: Which Has the Most Accurate Real Estate Data?
No vendor proves "most accurate," so here is what each one actually publishes, and how to test it yourself.
Tennessee, Goliath Teammate
Key Takeaways
- No independent test ranks ListSource, PropStream and Goliath Data on accuracy; Goliath publishes a skip trace accuracy figure (85%, with a 99% match rate), and none was found on the ListSource or PropStream pages read.
- ListSource's site says new registrations are no longer available, and its old Cotality address forwards to Cotality's Property List.
- PropStream is self-serve, with plans from $99 to $699/mo and a seven-day trial with 50 free leads; it lists 160+ million property records.
- Goliath Data plans cost $1,499, $2,999 and $7,499 a month, with no trial and no budget solo plan.
- Match rate, record accuracy, freshness and contact accuracy are four different measures; a match rate only says a number came back.
You are reading a guide written by Goliath Data, which is one of the three services compared. Figures and features were taken from each company's own pages on November 5, 2026, and they can change.
For ListSource vs PropStream, the honest answer is that no independent test we could find ranks these three on accuracy. Coverage claims are similar and each vendor describes its data differently. Goliath publishes a skip trace accuracy number, and we did not find one on the ListSource or PropStream pages we read. ListSource also has a more basic problem: its site says new registrations are no longer available. For most investors starting today, the practical comparison is PropStream or Goliath, with Cotality's newer product worth a call.
If you searched "list source vs propstream," or "propstream vs listsource," this is the same comparison.
What does "accurate" mean for real estate lead data?
Vendors blur three different things. Keep them apart when you read any data claim:
- Record accuracy: is this the right owner, loan and equity picture?
- Freshness: how soon does a new filing or sale reach your list?
- Contact accuracy: does the phone number reach the owner?
A match rate is none of these. It only says a number came back. Match rates hover around 99% across tools, which is why accuracy, not match rate, is the figure worth demanding.
ListSource vs PropStream vs Goliath on published claims
Goliath is first because it publishes figures on freshness and contact accuracy, not because it wins each row. Coverage is the row where the other two have the stronger published figures.
Published item | Goliath | ListSource | PropStream |
|---|---|---|---|
Coverage claim | Signal-based lists; varies by market | "94% of all property owners" and "99% coverage of all U.S. properties" | 160+ million property records |
Update claim | Hourly, with timing varying by source and market | "Updated daily" | Not stated as a schedule on pages we read |
Source on each record | Yes | Not stated | Not stated |
Skip trace figures | 99% match, 85% accuracy, no charge for misses | Not found | "Enhanced multi-sourced"; no accuracy figure found |
Pricing | $1,499 to $7,499/mo | Per lead, or custom subscription | $99 to $699/mo |
Open to new users | Yes, by demo | Registration closed per its site | Yes, with a 7-day trial |
What is ListSource today?
ListSource built its name as a straightforward way to buy targeted mail lists. Its home page describes property, homeowner and demographic lists for many industries, including residential real estate, insurance and home improvement. It offers quick lists such as absentee owners and homes in foreclosure.
Its pricing page describes three paths: a custom-priced subscription, a "build and buy" option priced per lead with no long-term contract, and a license-and-resell option for bulk use. Published per-lead rates are not shown.
Here is what changed. A tooltip beside the registration button now reads "New registrations are no longer available," and list building is marked as available to eligible users after login. The footer still shows a 2023 CoreLogic copyright, and the old Cotality address for ListSource now forwards to Property List on Araya. We did not find a formal announcement connecting the two, so call the sales line shown on both sites (866-774-3282) if you are an existing customer or want a straight answer.
Property List itself looks capable. Cotality says the data comes from county public records, assessor offices and recorder agencies, refreshed daily. Filters cover ownership, mortgage, equity and foreclosure status, with likelihood-to-sell indicators, and marketing lists are scrubbed against DMAchoice preferences. Prices are not listed on the page, so expect a demo or sales conversation.
Fair credit: for direct mail to a defined audience, county-sourced data with a mail-preference scrub is a sensible foundation. It is built more for list buyers than for people who need to dial today.
What does PropStream offer today?
PropStream is the self-serve option of the three. You can start a seven-day trial with 50 free leads and be searching the same day.
For data depth, it lists 160+ million property records, 185+ million mortgages, 41+ million pre-foreclosures, 150+ million involuntary liens and 7+ billion document images. Those document images matter for accuracy. Pulling the recorded deed yourself is the fastest way to settle a questionable ownership record.
Its lead lists also carry definitions, which is more useful than it sounds. Vacant means flagged by the US Postal Service, for example, and tax delinquency means noted by the county assessor. Knowing where a flag comes from tells you how far to trust it.
Plans start at $99 a month for 25,000 saves and exports. Skip tracing is included on Pro ($199) and Elite ($699) through PropStream Connect, or via a $30 add-on on Essentials. We did not see an accuracy rate published for those traces, so sample them yourself.
What does Goliath Data offer today?
Goliath is data and software, and it does not sell leads. Instead of filters alone, lists come from property signals: pre-foreclosure filings, probate, tax delinquency, equity and tenure, absentee ownership, and expired or withdrawn listings. Each record keeps the source behind it, so you can see why an owner is on your list and check it.
Property and distress records update hourly, with the caveat that refresh timing varies by source and market. County publishing speed still sets an outer limit for anyone.
The published skip trace numbers are 99% match and 85% accuracy, and misses are not charged. Read 85% plainly: some numbers will still be wrong, on any platform. See how these stack up in our skip tracing comparison.
The rest of the platform is about what happens next. CRM, dialer and texting are built in, and David, an AI voice agent, handles calls and configured follow-up before handing off with the seller's history. Plans run $1,499, $2,999 and $7,499 a month, with no trial and no budget solo plan. That rules it out for many readers, which is fine. It targets teams, and Goliath vs PropStream lays out that decision.
How do you test lead accuracy yourself in one afternoon?
You do not need to take anyone's word, including ours. Before paying for any tool:
- Pick one county and one buy box.
- Pull 25 records from the tool you are testing.
- Check owner name and mailing address against the county assessor or recorder.
- Note how recent the newest pre-foreclosure filing is against the county's own records.
- Trace those 25 and call them. Log right person, wrong person and disconnected.
Twenty-five records will not give you a statistic. It will expose an obvious problem fast, though, and that is usually what you need. Do your calling test with the rules in mind: treat calls and texts as covered by telemarketing rules, and ask your lawyer whether your offers count. The Federal Trade Commission has a Do Not Call and telemarketing guide, and this paragraph is not legal advice.
Which platform should you pick?
Pick Goliath if a team needs signal-based lists with sources, published trace accuracy and outreach under one login.
Pick PropStream if you want self-serve data today at a low monthly price, with document images for checking records.
Look at Cotality's Property List if direct mail to tightly defined audiences is the job and a sales process does not bother you. ListSource itself makes sense mainly if you already have an account.
More on these vendors: DealMachine vs ListSource and ListSource vs BatchLeads.