How to Capture and Convert Expired Listing Leads
Step-by-step process for turning expired listings into new seller relationships.

Austin Beverigde
Tennessee
, Goliath Teammate
Are you struggling to convert expired listings into valuable leads? You’re not alone. Many real estate professionals find themselves unsure of how to approach these listings, which can feel like a missed opportunity. But with the right strategies, you can turn these expired listings into successful sales.
To capture and convert expired listing leads, start by researching the properties and understanding their previous market performance. Reach out to the owners with a personalized message that addresses their specific situation and offers a solution. Follow up consistently and provide valuable insights to build trust and rapport.
Understanding Expired Listings
Expired listings are properties that were on the market but didn’t sell before the listing agreement expired. This can happen for several reasons, including overpricing, poor marketing, or lack of interest. Understanding the reasons behind the expiration can help you tailor your approach.
Why Expired Listings Are Valuable
Expired listings represent a pool of motivated sellers who may still want to sell their property. They often have already invested time and money into the selling process, making them more likely to consider new offers. By approaching them with a fresh perspective, you can help them achieve their selling goals.
Steps to Capture Expired Listing Leads
1. Research the Expired Listings
Gather data on expired listings in your area. Look for details like the original listing price, days on market, and reasons for expiration. This information will help you understand what went wrong and how to position yourself as a solution.
2. Craft a Personalized Outreach Strategy
When reaching out to the owners of expired listings, personalize your message. Mention specific details about their property and express empathy for their situation. Offer a solution that addresses their pain points, such as a new marketing strategy or pricing adjustment.
3. Follow Up Consistently
Don’t expect to convert leads with a single outreach. Follow up regularly with valuable insights, market updates, or even a simple check-in. Consistent communication builds trust and keeps you top-of-mind.
4. Provide Value Through Insights
Share market analysis or tips that can help the seller understand the current market conditions. This positions you as a knowledgeable resource and can help them feel more confident in working with you.
5. Schedule a Meeting
Once you’ve established rapport, aim to schedule a face-to-face meeting or a virtual consultation. This allows you to discuss their needs in-depth and present your tailored plan to sell their property.
Example Scenario
Consider a homeowner who had their property listed for six months at $500,000 but received no offers. After reaching out, you discover they didn’t receive sufficient marketing exposure. By proposing a comprehensive marketing plan that includes social media advertising and virtual tours, you can help them relist the property effectively. After your intervention, the property sells for $480,000 within a month.
Checklist for Capturing Expired Listing Leads
Research expired listings in your area.
Identify reasons for expiration.
Craft personalized outreach messages.
Follow up consistently with valuable insights.
Schedule meetings to discuss their needs.
Prepare a tailored marketing plan for their property.
Monitor the market for changes that may affect their selling strategy.
Build a relationship based on trust and transparency.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
When working with expired listings, there are several pitfalls to avoid:
Using a generic approach: Personalization is key. A one-size-fits-all message can come off as insincere.
Neglecting follow-ups: Many leads require multiple touchpoints before converting.
Focusing solely on price: While pricing is important, addressing the seller's emotional journey is equally crucial.
Being overly aggressive: High-pressure tactics can push sellers away. Approach them with empathy.
Failing to provide value: Always aim to offer useful information that can help the seller.
FAQs
What are expired listings?
Expired listings are properties that were listed for sale but did not sell before the listing agreement expired. These listings can provide opportunities for real estate agents to connect with motivated sellers.
How do I find expired listings?
You can find expired listings through multiple listing services (MLS), real estate websites, or by networking with other agents. Many platforms allow you to filter listings by their status, including expired listings.
What should I say when contacting expired listings?
When contacting expired listings, personalize your message by mentioning specific details about their property. Express empathy for their situation and offer a solution that addresses their needs, such as a new marketing strategy.
How often should I follow up with expired listings?
Follow up consistently, but avoid being overly aggressive. A good rule of thumb is to reach out every couple of weeks with valuable insights or updates, ensuring you remain top-of-mind without overwhelming them.
Can I convert all expired listings?
While not every expired listing will convert, many sellers are still motivated to sell. By approaching them with a genuine understanding of their situation and offering tailored solutions, you can increase your chances of success.
